Sell us cards
We buy Magic: The Gathering singles, plus select Pokémon and Union Arena cards. We don’t buy cards from other trading card games.
What we buy
- Magic singles worth up to $300 on Face to Face Games. We may still pass on cards in this range if we don’t have buyers for them.
- Rares and mythics. Commons and uncommons only when they’re worth at least $7.00 on Face to Face, or as part of a collection.
- Please sort your cards alphabetically by set, then alphabetically within each set. Sorted cards are done first.
The full list of cards we do and don’t take is in the selling singles terms.
How it works
It depends on how many cards you bring.
Up to 10 cards
Walk-in
Bring up to ten cards per person, per day, and we’ll go through them while you wait.
If other customers need help, we may pause to serve them first. Thanks for your patience.
More than 10, under 500 cards
Leave-in trade
Leave your cards with us along with your name and a phone number we can reach you on. Tell us whether you’d like cash or store credit.
We go through them as time allows and call you with a total. Then come in whenever it suits you to collect your payment or credit and any cards we didn’t take. Larger trades can take a week or more, so please wait for our call before coming back.
500 cards or more
Collection
We take collections case by case. Email us first and talk with Keith, the owner, before bringing a collection in.
Cash or store credit
Store credit is worth more: we pay 70% of our price in credit, or 40% in cash. The pricing guide shows exactly how we work out each card’s price.
These guidelines can change at our staff’s discretion. An exception made once doesn’t mean it will be made again.